Confession culture versus dating culture

· dating, advice

The stereotypical modern "Western" way to ask someone out is as follows: you just go like "hey gurl, wanna go out on a date" and then you take her to Waffle House or something and then over the course of a few more dates you see if you get along, and eventually you guys have "the talk" and become exclusive. Call this dating culture.

But traditionally, SG (and likely rest of Southeast/East Asia as well) has a different set of norms around asking someone out, which I call "traditional confession culture". It works like this:

You meet or know a girl[1] in a platonic context. You like her. But you mustn't tell her right away. Instead, you must slowly get to know her better by spending time together in plausibly-deniable platonic-ish contexts, like doing homework or playing frisbee over weeks and months, before formally declaring your attraction to her in a ritualised "confession".

There are rules around this confession. You can only confess to one person, ergo, you can only like or be interested in one person at a time even (especially) before they've said yes; to do otherwise would be "not serious" about them, like your desire is too diffuse and therefore not genuine. In dating culture, it's OK to be dating multiple people at once to see which one you like best. You also can't confess too early otherwise you don't come across as serious enough (apparently in Japan it's traditional for men to confess on exactly the third date[2]).

And this "confession" is very serious! You have to arrange the right moment, you have to prepare a speech, sit her down and open your heart up to her, maybe even buy flowers. You also go directly into a monogamous and committed relationship. If she agrees you guys are now "official" or "steady" and Boyfriend and Girlfriend; there is no liminal "casual" or "situationship" state.

Examples of confession culture

This Taiwanese movie set in the 90s, 那些年,我們一起追的女孩, or You Are the Apple of My Eye, shows confession culture super well:

Here's an account of what dating in the 90s was like in Singapore:

Before go out, must make hair nice nice, put the sharp comb, if the group got the girl you like, then even more exciting, got chance talk to her, other ppl walk in front, you talk to her and slow down your pace until you all last, or even better, your buddies purposely lose both of you.

Notice no 1-1 dates, because romantic intent has not been declared: only stolen snippets of alone time on platonic group outings.

Quite easy to stead, and very fast can do a lot liao. Initially also very exciting, move jin fast, she always call you 老公 and talk about marriage like 2 weeks in. Must buy ring from 77th street, wear around like engagement ring, jin romantic.

"stead" == "going steady", and what would be considered as being extremely presumptuous in dating culture (calling someone 老公 (husband) after two weeks)

Now can laugh laugh at it, but remember last time you jio the ah lian, she say yes, also feel very very happy. Before you say the 你要做我的 stead 吗? feel jin nervous. Got some say no, then feel very sad, but ok, go pak some KOF in arcade, then feel good liao.

See exactly the confession: "你要做我的 stead 吗?" ("Do you want to be my 'stead' (girlfriend)?")

Pros and cons of confession culture

👍 Lets people down gently. Confession culture gives you plausible deniability. Confession culture lets people get rejected without losing face -- in Chinese we say 給人機會下台 (give someone a chance to walk off the stage, ergo let them down gently). If the girl is aware but not interested, she will show signs of disinterest and hope the guy backs off, and if the guy gets the hint he will indeed back off, without anyone's feelings being hurt too much.

👎 Bad for low EQ people. The flip side of plausible deniability is a lack of legibility. Precisely because traditional confession culture is less direct, it requires a lot of "reading the room", which is difficult for those on the spectrum. If the guy doesn't get the hint (or sometimes the girl is oblivious, or just stringing him along), then the guy is really going to eat shit when he confesses.

👍 More commitment-minded. Men will usually be happy to be in a short-term sexual relationship with a girl they don't see themselves becoming serious with. In modern dating culture this is a serious source of consternation to the girl and why there is a lot of discourse around "The Talk", "defining the relationship", "are you seeing anyone else", "what are we", etc. Confession culture doesn't have this problem, since the only two acceptable states are platonic friends or serious monogamous relationship. The long process also acts as a costly signal which forces "better" (more committed) behaviour from men, and filters out cads; only serious suitors need apply..

👎 Encourages obsession. Traditional confession culture encourages a sort of obsession that isn't warranted IMO. Our instincts naturally drive us to limerence and obsession, and confession culture just amps that up. I think this is unhealthy and unrealistic and not conducive to long-term relationship success. You want to enter a relationship as clear-eyed as you can despite your hormones, but this is doing the opposite.


Advice to autists who find themselves in confession culture

Confession culture (or Eastern guess-not-ask cultures more generally) can be difficult to navigate for autists.

These three things worked for me but your mileage may vary:

  1. Confess quickly but lightly
  2. Embrace rejection
  3. Don't take no as final answer (be careful with this)

Confess quickly but lightly. Neurotypical people only confess if they are pretty sure they'll be accepted. We don't have that luxury: because we're not good at reading and interpreting nonverbal signals, we find ourselves in the "confess to someone who's not interested and eat shit" portion of the flowchart more often than not (ask me how I know...).

To avoid this, I think you should head things off at the pass: establish romantic intent quickly and "lightly". Most men know if they find a woman physically attractive within minutes if not seconds, and I think it's good to let her know that early[3]. It clears the air[4], establishes your intent so she's not blindsided later ("I thought we were just friends!"), or if she really has no interest whatsoever, can quickly withdraw.

What is "keeping it light"? Golden mean: you do really like her, you're not indifferent about dating her, but at the same time, you're not going to die without her. Your attitude should be something like "I am very keen to pursue a relationship with you, but if you don't want to, that's OK and I respect your decision."

Embrace rejection. Court rejection quickly and don't be afraid of it. In 1:09:03 of the movie he confesses to her. After his confession she asks, "Do you want to know the answer? I can tell you right now" and he says "No, I didn't ask you so you can't turn me down. Please don't turn me down. Just let me keep on liking you."

This is -- not to mince words -- an extremely retarded thing to do. She was going to say yes you doofus!!! The moral of the story here is: don't be a pussy and let your fear of rejection stop you from finding love. The truth is that rejection is a fact of life and one should actively court it; the sooner one gets over one's fear of rejection, the better one's life will be. (Rejection hurts, but you do get more comfortable with it with with age.)

This is another reason to confess early, BTW. The more effort and emotional investment you put in, the more you ruminate, the more you'll have riding on the outcome and the worse you'll feel if she rejects you.

I also think the gentlemanly thing to do is to make it as easy as you can for her to say no to you, as a kindness to her:

Treat the people whom you ask things from with the utmost respect and kindness. It's hard to say no, so make it as easy as you can for the other person. If you ask to work with someone, and they say no, maybe they don't have a vacancy, maybe you're not skilled enough yet, no worries, thank you for considering me in any case. If you ask someone out and they say no, okay that sucks, but hey, absolutely no worries at all, totally understand, respect your decision. And then tell yourself: it was a long shot anyway, I'm glad I asked!

Finally, even if she says no, it's not the end of the world, because...

Don't take "no" as final. Be careful with this! You should definitely think whether you should reverse this advice. With that caveat, no means no, but... sometimes not really? I don't think you should give up for good after the first no. For one, girls in general take longer to warm up to a potential partner. The no may turn into a yes after she gets to know you better.

And second, some girls actually like it when you persist after a rejection. If you ask folks in your parents' or grandparents' generation you'll find that this social script was very well understood. I know a couple in their 60s, Scott and Nisa, that have been happily married for over four decades now: I once asked Scott how they got together and he said something like "it was love at first sight for me but it took her a couple years to come around."[5]

To be clear, sometimes no really does mean no; you don't want to be "that pushy guy who can't take no for an answer". Exercise proper judgement.

Thoughts on modern dating culture

The ubiquity of Hinge et al. has shifted all of us from "confession culture" to "dating culture". You swiped on each other, after all; no confession needed. In fact I think the dating app is dating culture on steroids. You swipe on hundreds of people, date multiple people at once, and compared to dating IRL or in friend circles, there are no social networks to enforce behavioural norms or warn of bad actors.

Dating apps are now the dominant way of meeting new people, but dating app fatigue also seems near-universal, so I wonder if we would be better served by a return to tradition. Girls generally like being desired and "chased" (consumers of romantasy or romance anything skew very disproportionately female), which is exactly what confession culture requires. I think this is a great way for confident and commitment-minded men to differentiate themselves: after all, any Marl can swipe on the apps, but not many men would dare to put themselves out there.

As a washed-up unc, I'm not privy to how youths date today. But in my adolescence the "confession" model was the dominant one; it was how everyone got together. I'd love to know whether "confession culture" is still alive and well today.

Thanks to Chew, Donald, Wise, and Woo for their contributions to this post.


  1. In this essay I'm going to use the example of a guy confessing to a girl, but obviously any permutation of genders is possible, so feel free to replace "she" or "her" with "the person being confessed to" throughout. ↩︎

  2. In fact, in traditional confession culture, the notion of a "date" is quite foreign; a date is usually something you do after you get together, not before. ↩︎

  3. There is some value in getting to know a girl a little better before asking her out, but short of obvious disqualifiers I don't think you can get much signal because people behave very differently in platonic relationships versus intimate ones. So I think it's better to ask early. ↩︎

  4. For me, letting a woman know early that I find her attractive acts as a "pressure release valve" regardless of her response: I no longer feel like I'm hiding my desire from her, which makes me more at ease in my words and actions. ↩︎

  5. Another note on persistence: traditionally you're supposed to be obsessed with only one girl, and I have seen this work for some, but I think it's not healthy to do that. Even if you like a particular girl very much and want to continue pursuing her, I'd recommend against being too single-minded in that pursuit: as much as possible, you should meet as many girls as you can in all sorts of contexts. There are many wonderful people out there and it will help you come across as earnest but not desperate if you genuinely feel like you have options. ↩︎